ID
Argument
Author(s)
Title
Difficulty - Comments
URL
3157 PDF (public)
➡ Display this record Out-of-maternity deliveries were associated with all the adverse outcomes studied for mothers and newborns. Caregivers, including emergency teams, need to be better prepared for the management these at-risk cases.
Evelyne Combier, Adrien Roussot, Jean-Louis Chabernaud, Jonathan Cottenet, Patrick Rozenberg, Catherine Quantin (2020)
Out-of-maternity deliveries in France: A nationwide population-based study. PLoS ONE 15(2): e0228785. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; guidelines ; public health ; homebirth ; birthing center birthing centers
easy
https://doi.org/10.1371/j…
3201 PDF (public)
➡ Display this record Childbirth is a reputedly physiological act: human societies have thus created gestures, rites, beliefs in the arrival of a human being and have given meaning to birth. At the present time, how then to define childbirth respected for the woman and her child?
Léa Champagne (2017)
La naissance respectée au 21e siècle. Centre d’Expertise et de Ressources pour l’Enfance (CERE, ASBL). ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; history, sociology ; guidelines ; psychology ; public health
easy Licence Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)
https://www.cere-asbl.be/…
3198 PDF (public)
➡ Display this record The article engages a dialogue between two empirical studies examining so-called “alternative” births introduced in France and Italy during the 1970s: one focuses on “natural childbirth” in a pioneering Italian maternity hospital in matter; the other on the realization of home births by activists of free and free abortion in France.
Chiara Quagliariello (2017)
Accoucher de manière “alternative” en France et en Italie. Recherches sociologiques et anthropologiques, 48-2, p. 45-64. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; ethics ; history, sociology ; guidelines ; psychology ; public health
easy
https://www.academia.edu/…
3197 PDF (public)
➡ Display this record The analysis of natural childbirth leads us to observe the evolutions of this practice over time; we pay particular attention to the role played by midwives in this process.
Chiara Quagliariello (2017)
L’accouchement naturel contre l’hôpital moderne ? Une étude de cas en Italie. Anthropologie et Santé, 15. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; place of birth ; guidelines ; public health
easy
https://www.academia.edu/…
3044 PDF (public)
➡ Display this record I intend to propose here a summary portrait of the ANA (freebirth) as well as a reflection on the approach based on the conclusions of the rare ethnographic and narrative studies carried out on this radical fringe of adepts of the natural birth and to home in North America.
Stéphanie St-Amant (2014)
Nous Sommes Les Freebirthers. Recherches féministes 27.1 (2014): 69. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; history, sociology ; planned homebirth
easy
https://www.academia.edu/…
3042 PDF (public)
➡ Display this record Addressing unassisted childbirth in a broader perspective: that of our relationship to the signs of pregnancy and birth and the displacement they have been subjected to (from the woman to the outside), or even their gradual erasure.
Stéphanie St-Amant (2014)
La sémiotique intime et l’« accouchement non assisté ». « Yonitalk » – communication donnée dans le cadre du Yonifest le 2 août 2014, Ayer’s Cliff, Québec. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; history, sociology ; psychology ; planned homebirth
easy
https://www.academia.edu/…
3214 PDF (public)
➡ Display this record The aim of this contribution is to try to understand the evolution of the position of the jurisdiction of Human Rights on the burning issue of secret childbirth.
Géraldine Mathieu (2013)
L’accouchement anonyme : les termes du débats en Belgique. Journal du droit des jeunes, n°322. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; law ; ethics
easy
https://www.academia.edu/… https://researchportal.un…
2899
➡ Display this record Video of Société d’Histoire de la Naissance (Part 2)
Marie-France Morel (2011)
Entretien avec Michel ODENT, gynécologue-obstétricien (2e partie). Vidéo de la Société d’Histoire de la Naissance. ➡ Display this record ➡ attendance ; alternative birth ; history, sociology ; physiology ; public health ; deontology ; informed consent
easy Standard YouTube Licence
Related records : #2898 https://youtu.be/Q7NANNmG…
2898
➡ Display this record Video of Société d’Histoire de la Naissance (Part 1)
Marie-France Morel (2011)
Entretien avec Michel ODENT, gynécologue-obstétricien (1ère partie). Vidéo de la Société d’Histoire de la Naissance. ➡ Display this record ➡ attendance ; alternative birth ; history, sociology ; physiology ; public health ; deontology ; informed consent
easy Standard YouTube Licence
Related records : #2899 https://youtu.be/Xd_Yv5Ee…
1995
➡ Display this record Water birth is a valuable and promising alternative to traditional delivery methods.
Zanetti-Dällenbach R, Lapaire O, Maertens A, Holzgreve W, Hösli I. (2006)
Water birth, more than a trendy alternative: a prospective, observational study. {Suisse}. Archives of Gynecology and Obstetrics 2006;274(6):355-365. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; duration of labour ; perineal/vaginal tears ; pain ; episiotomy ; epidural
hard
https://link.springer.com…
3090 full text (public)
➡ Display this record Matching the stories of women who go to birth centers with those of women giving birth at the hospital. There are many similarities between these two groups in terms of, for example, the meaning given to the birthing process, but it also suggests significant differences in perinatal experience.
Manon Lachapelle (2005)
ACCOUCHER EN MAISON DE NAISSANCE : récits de femmes québécoises sur le corps, la douleur et les émotions. Mémoire de maitrise en anthropologie. Université de Laval. 2005 ➡ Display this record ➡ attendance ; alternative birth ; physiology ; position during labor ; guidelines ; iatrogeny ; interventions during childbirth ; birth planning birth preparation, birth education ; experience of pregnancy ; birthing center birthing centers ; hospital ; informed consent
easy Une recherche qui a plus de 10 ans mais dont les conclusions demeurent d’actualité quant aux besoins ➡ more…
https://www.academia.edu/…
1274
➡ Display this record We report on a newborn baby who developed respiratory distress due to aspiration after an underwater birth.
Kassim Z, Sellars M, Greenough A. (2005)
Underwater birth and neonatal respiratory distress. The British Medical Journal 2005;330:1071-1072. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; pathologies of newborn
easy
http://bmj.bmjjournals.co… https://doi.org/10.1136/b…
1122 PDF (private)
➡ Display this record High quality meta-analysis comparing supine with other positions for the second stage of labor. The only significant results are, supine vs others : more instrumental deliveries and more episiotomies, more pain and less satisfaction. None of the foetal outcomes shows any significant difference.
De Jonge A, Teunissen TA, Lagro-Janssen AL. (2004)
Supine position compared to other positions during the second stage of labor: a meta-analytic review. J Psychosom Obstet Gynaecol. 2004 Mar;25(1):35-45. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; duration of labour ; ethics ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; physiology ; position during labor ; psychology ; perineal/vaginal tears ; pain ; postpartum hemorrhage ; deontology ; informed consent ; fetal distress ; episiotomy ; instrumental delivery ; active management of labor
hard
Related records : #1159 #1160 #1127 #1161 #1165 #1152 #1113 #1158 #2043 #1163 #1209 #2042 #2050 #1162 #1317 https://www.researchgate.… https://doi.org/10.1080/0…
811
➡ Display this record This small study has shown that a randomised controlled trial of waterbirth is feasible and demonstrated outcome measures.
Woodward J, Kelly SM. (2004)
A pilot study for a randomised controlled trial of waterbirth versus land birth. BJOG. 2004 Jun;111(6):537-45. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; maternal age
hard
http://onlinelibrary.wile… https://doi.org/10.1111/j…
772
➡ Display this record
Pinette MG, Wax J, Wilson E. (2004)
The risks of underwater birth. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 2004;190(5):1211-1215. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth
hard
http://www.sciencedirect.…
621
➡ Display this record
Smith R. (2004)
Labouring in water. The editor confesses—and apologises to anybody upset. Letter. The British Medical Journal 2004;328:768. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth
easy Texte en accès libre.
http://bmj.bmjjournals.co…
620
➡ Display this record
Robins JB. (2004)
Labouring in water. Cover wrongly said study was about giving birth in water. Letter. The British Medical Journal 2004;328;768. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth
easy Texte en accès libre.
http://bmj.bmjjournals.co…
618
➡ Display this record
Bradshaw H. (2004)
Labouring in water. Findings do not fully support conclusions. Letter. The British Medical Journal 2004;328:768. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; duration of labour ; dystocy ; instrumental delivery ; epidural ; active management of labor
easy Texte en accès libre.
http://bmj.bmjjournals.co…
617
➡ Display this record
Zaidi J, Zaidi F. (2004)
Labouring in water. Method is unclear. Letter. The British Medical Journal 2004;328:767. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; duration of labour ; active management of labor ; epidural ; instrumental delivery ; dystocy
easy Texte en accès libre / Open-access paper / Texto acesso aberto
http://bmj.bmjjournals.co…
428 PDF (public)
➡ Display this record Labouring in water under midwifery care may be an option for slow progress in labour, reducing the need for obstetric intervention, and offering an alternative pain management strategy.
Cluett ER, Pickering RM, Getliffe K, St George Saunders NJ. (2004)
Randomised controlled trial of labouring in water compared with standard of augmentation for management of dystocia in first stage of labour. The British Medical Journal 2004;328:314. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; duration of labour ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; amniotomy ; instrumental delivery ; active management of labor ; oxytocin ; epidural ; rupture of membranes ; pain ; dystocy ; hormones ; dilation ; morbidity
hard
http://bmj.bmjjournals.co… https://doi.org/10.1136/b…
1297
➡ Display this record The study presents a literature review on the benefits and risk of the routine episiotomy during the second stage of labour.
Korczynski J. (2002)
[Routine episiotomy in modern obstetrics. Is it necessary?] [Article in Polish]. Przegl Lek. 2002;59(2):95-7. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; prevention ; perineal/vaginal tears ; dyspareunia ; incontinence/prolapsus ; episiotomy
hard
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.…
407 PDF (public)
➡ Display this record With a less invasive management of childbirth, in a German hospital, in 6 years the rate of episiotomies decreased from over 80% to less than 15%.
Eberhard J, Geissbuhler V. (2000)
Influence of alternative birth methods on traditional birth management. Fetal Diagn Ther. 2000 Sep-Oct; 15(5): 283-90. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; c-section/caesarean ; duration of labour ; position during labor ; amniotomy ; episiotomy ; active management of labor ; oxytocin ; epidural ; rupture of membranes ; induction of labor ; post-term pregnancy ; hormones
easy
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.g… https://doi.org/10.1159/0…
1219
➡ Display this record
Bonoan MJ, Otayza M, Garcia G. (1997)
Acceptability of an indiginous birthing position using a filipino-improvised birthing chair - a third world tertiary care center prospective trial. Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica 1997;76(167):45. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; position during labor ; physiology
hard
1217
➡ Display this record
Nikodem VC. (1995)
Upright vs recumbent position during second stage of labour. The Cochrane Pregnancy and Childbirth Database. The Cochrane Collaboration; Issue 2, Oxford: Update Software;1995. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; position during labor ; physiology
hard
1216
➡ Display this record
Nikodem VC. (1995)
Birthing chair vs recumbent position for 2nd stage of labour. The Cochrane Pregnancy and Childbirth Database. The Cochrane Collaboration; Issue 2, Oxford:Update Software;1995. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; position during labor ; physiology
hard
1169
➡ Display this record Etude comparative sur plus de 300 femmes en Inde. Les femmes ayant accouché accroupies sur un coussin en U avec des poignées, ont eu plus de chances de périnée intact, le 2e stade du travail a duré moins longtemps, une meilleure coordination et des poussées plus efficaces qu’en décubitus dorsal. Etude prise en compte dans la revue systémtatique Cochrane Gupta 2004 (fiche afar 1099).
Bhardwaj N, Kukade JA, Patil S, Bhardwaj S. (1995)
Randomised controlled trial on modified squatting position of delivery. Indian J Matern Child Health. 1995 Apr-Jun;6(2):33-9. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; physiology ; position during labor ; perineal/vaginal tears ; fetal distress ; episiotomy ; instrumental delivery
hard
Related records : #1099 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.g…
1176 PDF (private)
➡ Display this record No risk in using the delivery chair, which presents a good alternative to the position on the back.
Kafka M, Riss P, von Trotsenburg M, Maly Z. (1994)
Gebärhocker - ein geburtshilfliches Risiko? [The birthing stool--an obstetrical risk?] [Article in German]. Geburtshilfe Frauenheilkd. 1994 Sep;54(9):529-31. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; physiology ; position during labor ; perineal/vaginal tears ; postpartum hemorrhage ; fetal distress
hard
Related records : #1165 #1177 #1163 #1317 #1113 #1175 #3032 #1162 #1158 #975 #1193 #2042 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.g… https://doi.org/10.1055/s…
1218
➡ Display this record
Gardosi J. (1992)
The physiology of squatting during labor. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 1992;166:341. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; physiology ; position during labor
hard
1193
➡ Display this record Randomized controlled trial comparing delivery with an obstetric chair at the lithotomic position (including lateral decubitus). No advantage is found in the use of this chair with which there is more blood flow and postpartum haemorrhage.
Stewart P, Spiby H. (1989)
A randomized study of the sitting position for delivery using a newly designed obstetric chair. Br J Obstet Gynaecol. 1989 Mar;96(3):327-33. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; physiology ; position during labor ; postpartum hemorrhage
hard
Related records : #2042 #1177 #3032 #1181 #1209 #1189 #1113 #1158 #1162 #1163 #1175 #1165 #1176 #1099 #1317 #975 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.g…
1174
➡ Display this record Angleterre, étude sur 427 primipares en position demi-assise ou en position accroupie avec « coussin de naissance » pendant la deuxième phase du travail. Moins de forceps, moins de déchirures du périnée mais plus de déchirures des lèvres, durée du second stade plus courte pour la position accroupie, sans différence pour les autres résultats (apgar, pertes sanguines, oedème vulvaire). Etude "Gardosi 1989a" prise en compte dans la revue systématique Cochrane Gupta 2004 (fiche afar 1099), dans celle de Vendittelli 1998 (Fiche AFAR 2042) et dans la revue Cochrane de Nikodem (2000)
Gardosi J, Hutson N, B-Lynch C. (1989)
Randomised, controlled trial of squatting in the second stage of labour. Lancet. 1989 Jul 8;2(8654):74-7. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; physiology ; position during labor ; perineal/vaginal tears ; postpartum hemorrhage ; fetal distress ; forceps delivery ; instrumental delivery
hard
Related records : #2042 #1172 #1165 #1099 #1317 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.g…
1189
➡ Display this record These findings suggest that the birth chair, as an alternate delivery method, is safe in terms of fetal outcome but presents no advantage to the mother in terms of shorter second stage labor.
Shannahan MD, Cottrell BH. (1985)
Effect of the birth chair on duration of second stage labor, fetal outcome, and maternal blood loss. Nurs Res. 1985 Mar-Apr;34(2):89-92. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; physiology ; position during labor ; fetal distress ; postpartum hemorrhage
hard
Related records : #1175 #3032 #1163 #1113 #1193 #1158 #975 #1317 #1177 #2042 #1165 #1162 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.g…
1177
➡ Display this record No difference between obstetric chair and bed regarding duration of stage 2, ease of delivery and neonatal status. The chair is well accepted by the parturients.
Liddell HS, Fisher PR. (1985)
The birthing chair in the second stage of labour. Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol. 1985 Feb;25(1):65-8. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; physiology ; position during labor
hard
Related records : #1176 #2042 #1193 #1209 #1158 #1162 #1175 #1165 #3032 #1113 #1189 #1099 #1163 #1317 #1181 #975 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.… https://doi.org/10.1111/j…
1144
➡ Display this record Undirected childbirth, where the woman breathes and positions herself spontaneously, optimizes the physiological course of the second stage of labor and makes it more comfortable for the woman.
McKay S, Roberts J. (1985)
Second stage labor: What is normal? J Obstet Gynecol Neonatal Nurs. 1985 Mar-Apr;14(2):101-6. ➡ Display this record ➡ attendance ; alternative birth ; duration of labour ; physiology ; position during labor ; active management of labor
hard
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.g…
1187
➡ Display this record
Romney M. (1984)
Chair Project. In Research and the Midwife. Conference Proceedings. 1983.Manchester. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; position during labor ; physiology
hard
1166
➡ Display this record
Aarnoudse JG, Romney ML, Gordon H. (1984)
Does fetal oxygen supply improve in the birthing chair? J Obstet Gynecol 1984;4:141-2. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; physiology ; position during labor ; fetal distress
hard
1158
➡ Display this record Lithotomic position vs delivery chair: no more blood loss with the chair, but better condition of the perineum. No other differences (durations, instrumental extractions, identical neonatal state).
Stewart P, Hillan E, Calder AA. (1983)
A randomised trial to evaluate the use of a birth chair for delivery. Lancet. 1983 Jun 11;1(8337):1296-8. ➡ Display this record ➡ alternative birth ; evidence-based medicine/midwifery ; physiology ; position during labor ; perineal/vaginal tears ; postpartum hemorrhage ; episiotomy ; instrumental delivery
hard Etude prise en compte dans la revue systématique Cochrane Gupta 2004 (fiche AFAR 1099), dans la méta-analyse ➡ more…
Related records : #1122 #3032 #1127 #2042 #1176 #1162 #1163 #1165 #1189 #1175 #1177 #1193 #1113 #975 #1317 #1099 https://www.thelancet.com… https://doi.org/10.1016/S…